America’s honor

Article author: 
Scott Johnson
Article publisher: 
Article date: 
30 May 2016
Article category: 
National News
Article Body: 

In observance of Memorial Day 2007 the Wall Street Journal published a characteristically brilliant column by Peter Collier to mark the occasion... I don’t think we’ll read or hear anything more thoughtful or appropriate to the occasion today. Here it is:

American Honor, by Peter Collier, Wall Street Journal, May 26, 2007. Read the full article at PowerLine: America’s honor.

Once we knew who and what to honor on Memorial Day: those who had given all their tomorrows, as was said of the men who stormed the beaches of Normandy, for our todays. But in a world saturated with selfhood, where every death is by definition a death in vain, the notion of sacrifice today provokes puzzlement more often than admiration. We support the troops, of course, but we also believe that war, being hell, can easily touch them with an evil no cause for engagement can wash away. And in any case we are more comfortable supporting them as victims than as warriors.

Former football star Pat Tillman and Marine Cpl. Jason Dunham were killed on the same day: April 22, 2004. But as details of his death fitfully emerged from Afghanistan, Tillman has become a metaphor for the current conflict–a victim of fratricide, disillusionment, coverup and possibly conspiracy. By comparison, Dunham, who saved several of his comrades in Iraq by falling on an insurgent’s grenade, is the unknown soldier. The New York Times, which featured Abu Ghraib on its front page for 32 consecutive days, put the story of Dunham’s Medal of Honor on the third page of section B.

Not long ago I was asked to write the biographical sketches for a book featuring formal photographs of all our living Medal of Honor recipients. As I talked with them, I was, of course, chilled by the primal power of their stories. But I also felt pathos: They had become strangers–honored strangers, but strangers nonetheless–in our midst.


We impoverish ourselves by shunting these heroes and their experiences to the back pages of our national consciousness. Their stories are not just boys’ adventure tales writ large. They are a kind of moral instruction. They remind of something we’ve heard many times before but is worth repeating on a wartime Memorial Day when we’re uncertain about what we celebrate. We’re the land of the free for one reason only: We’re also the home of the brave. 

Read the full article at PowerLine: America’s honor.

Peter’s book on the living Medal of Honor recipients is Medal of Honor: Portraits of Valor Beyond the Call of Duty, now republished in a third edition.


Related articles

The Unfinished Memorial Day for the Men Who Saved America, Brietbart, May 26, 2016.

War Crimes of Imperial Japan: A Lesson In Moral Equivalence for Mr. Obama, ​by John Hayward, Breitbart, May 27, 2016.

Congress Must Censure President Obama over Hiroshima Speech, by Joel B. Pollak, Breitbart, May 27, 2016.

A surreal day in America’s war against ISIS, by Richard Whittle, New York Post, May 28, 2016.